Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Bennie Logan
Eagles Forum > Philadelphia Eagles Message Board > Philadelphia Eagles or Football Related Discussion
Zero
PFF doesn't seem to have a very high opinion of Bennie Logan. They have him listed as the 35th best available interior defensive lineman? Am I reading this right? If we eliminate the RFAs and players 30 or over that still makes him 21st on the list. Are we over rating him or is there something I'm not seeing here? I also get that there is a difference between 4-3 and a 3-4 player.
Calais Campbell 90.4 DI 31 Cardinals 831 UFA
Kawann Short 87.7 DI 28 Panthers 779 UFA
Chris I. Baker 82.2 DI 29 Redskins 782 UFA
Karl Klug 81.3 DI 29 Titans 399 UFA
Stacy McGee 80.5 DI 27 Raiders 242 UFA
Alan Branch 80.4 DI 32 Patriots 760 UFA
Dominique Easley 79.1 DI 25 Rams 470 RFA
Lawrence Guy 76.2 DI 27 Ravens 487 UFA
Brandon J. Williams 75.9 DI 28 Ravens 636 UFA
Stephen Paea 75.7 DI 29 Browns 319 UFA
C.J. (Clifford) Wilson 75.5 DI 30 Bears 128 UFA
Mike Pennel 73.2 DI 26 Packers 103 RFA
Cullen Jenkins 71.7 DI 36 Redskins 308 UFA
Cam Thomas 70.4 DI 30 Rams 391 UFA
Tony McDaniel 68.7 DI 32 Seahawks 501 UFA
Kedric Golston 66.7 DI 34 Redskins 30 UFA
Cornelius Washington 63.3 DI 27 Bears 364 UFA
Damion Square 60.7 DI 28 Chargers 362 UFA
Dontari Poe 55.8 DI 27 Chiefs 876 UFA
Jarvis Jenkins 48.6 DI 29 Chiefs 266 UFA
Devon Still 48.1 DI 28 Texans 25 UFA
Paul Soliai 47.6 DI 33 Panthers 152 UFA
Leger Douzable 47.3 DI 31 Bills 483 UFA
Johnathan Hankins 47.1 DI 25 Giants 816 UFA
Tyson Alualu 47.0 DI 30 Jaguars 508 UFA
Tony Jerod-Eddie 47.0 DI 27 49ers 85 UFA
Kerry Wynn 46.6 DI 26 Giants 131 RFA
Tyrunn Walker 46.4 DI 27 Lions 377 UFA
Jonathan Babineaux 46.3 DI 35 Falcons 533 UFA
John Hughes 46.1 DI 29 Buccaneers 86 UFA
Ricardo Mathews 45.7 DI 30 Steelers 330 UFA
Sealver Siliga 45.7 DI 28 Buccaneers 160 UFA
Stefan Charles 45.4 DI 29 Lions 235 UFA
Vince Wilfork 45.1 DI 35 Texans 587 UFA
Bennie Logan 45.1 DI 27 Eagles 467 UFA
Linc ...
nephillymike
I saw that.

Not too impressive.

There is a stat out there that when he played, the Eagles DL was much better. Not sure where I read that. I am not sure how those two reconcile.

Do you see anywhere how Logan rates vs our other DTs?

Our highest rated FA is Wiz. He's rated the 11th best OG out of 36. I'd like to think we'd bring him back after cutting Kelce to free up cap.
Zero
Walter Football breaks it down the 4-3 DTs, Benny is #6:
Kawann Short, DT, Panthers. Age: 28. ...
Calais Campbell, DE/DT, Cardinals. Age: 31. ...
Brandon Williams, NT, Ravens. Age: 28. ...
Chris Baker, DE/DT, Redskins. Age: 29. ...
Johnathan Hankins, NT, Giants. Age: 25. ...
Dontari Poe, NT, Chiefs. Age: 27. ...
Dominique Easley, DT, Rams. Age 25...
Bennie Logan, DT, Eagles. Age 27...
I wonder if these are strictly stat driven?

Here ...
Zero
Among FA DTs, Benny is #8 in QB hits, #6 in sacks, #2 in FF and #15 in tackles according to Spotrac.
nephillymike
THIS could approximate Logan's value per Spotrac for S. Williams:

http://www.spotrac.com/nfl/denver-broncos/...8/market-value/

Would you sign him to this deal?
Joegrane
Why do you think S Williams is a good comparison to B Logan?

Williams was a 1st rounder. Sporttrac compares Williams to various other DTs earning btw 3.5 and 4.5 mil$, not B Logan.

I'd expect Bennie's #s to be bloated somewhat playing next to a DT who is doubled so often.

I would certainly not pay 4.5 mil. I assume he is more of a 3.5 mil guy.

QUOTE (nephillymike @ Feb 26 2017, 10:20 AM) *
THIS could approximate Logan's value per Spotrac for S. Williams:

http://www.spotrac.com/nfl/denver-broncos/...8/market-value/

Would you sign him to this deal?

Zero
QUOTE (nephillymike @ Feb 26 2017, 10:20 AM) *
THIS could approximate Logan's value per Spotrac for S. Williams:

http://www.spotrac.com/nfl/denver-broncos/...8/market-value/

Would you sign him to this deal?

As long as there's money to buy a good CB, WR and maybe a G ... sure. You know numbers ain't my strength though.
Eyrie
I'd like Logan back. He's not a star, but he is a solid player and good compliment to Cox.

However the biggest problem is going to be our relative lack of cap room which is not helped by overpaying Cox and Curry.
nephillymike
QUOTE (Eyrie @ Feb 26 2017, 05:44 PM) *
I'd like Logan back. He's not a star, but he is a solid player and good compliment to Cox.

However the biggest problem is going to be our relative lack of cap room which is not helped by overpaying Cox and Curry.

Cox I don't mind as much as Curry.

Who was going to pay Curry big bucks?

They should have let him test the market and then signed him for millions less.
Eyrie
QUOTE (nephillymike @ Feb 26 2017, 10:59 PM) *
Cox I don't mind as much as Curry.

Who was going to pay Curry big bucks?

They should have let him test the market and then signed him for millions less.

We can only hope that Curry plays anywhere close to his contract, because with Barwin an inevitable cap casualty there is a vacancy to be filled by the guy who couldn't earn the starting job despite his overpriced contract last year.
Reality Fan
QUOTE (nephillymike @ Feb 26 2017, 05:59 PM) *
Cox I don't mind as much as Curry.

Who was going to pay Curry big bucks?

They should have let him test the market and then signed him for millions less.



I am curious....why doesn't Cox bother you? He was ok but when you isolate him he is not double teamed every play and for the money he is getting he should beat a double team more often than not...he was ok but he needs to be dominating every game
nephillymike
QUOTE (Reality Fan @ Feb 27 2017, 08:57 PM) *
I am curious....why doesn't Cox bother you? He was ok but when you isolate him he is not double teamed every play and for the money he is getting he should beat a double team more often than not...he was ok but he needs to be dominating every game


55th overall in the NFL.

Solid year.

Curry was a no show.

https://www.profootballfocus.com/pro-top-10...016-nfl-season/
Reality Fan
QUOTE (nephillymike @ Feb 27 2017, 09:20 PM) *
55th overall in the NFL.

Solid year.

Curry was a no show.

https://www.profootballfocus.com/pro-top-10...016-nfl-season/


I agree with Curry but for the money Cox got I was not impressed and I watched for him more as the year went on....disappointing....57 hurries....woohoo...in Schwartz's scheme that is weak
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2017 Invision Power Services, Inc.