Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Eagles Coach Scoreboard
Eagles Forum > Philadelphia Eagles Message Board > Philadelphia Eagles or Football Related Discussion
nephillymike
I heard Ray and Glenn this AM talking about the coaching candidates and rating them based on their opinions.

Piggybacking off that conversation, rate the following candidates in one of the four choices:

Love it
Like it
Just Ok with it
don't like it


The list of realistic candidates that I can think of:

Ex NFL coaches who may or may not be iterested in returning to coaching = Jon Gruden and Bill Cowher.

Ex NFL coaches who are interested = Lovie Smith

Current NFL coordinators = B. Arians, M. McCoy, Jay Gruden, G. Bradley

Current NCAA coaches = B. Kelly

Here's mine:
Love it = Cowher
Like it = Bradley, Jon Gruden
OK with it = Kelly, Smith, Arians
don't like it = McCoy, Jay Gruden

Anyone??
mcnabbulous
Love it - Bradley
Like it - McCoy
Ok with it - Jay, Lovie, Kelly, Arians
Don't like it - Jon, Cowher
Reality Fan
love it: Cowher or Bradley
like it: Lovie Smith

After that I don't really like any of them.

Gruden is a dick as a coach and his reputation precedes him into any locker room now.

McCoy had great passing numbers on the teams he OC'd before Peyton because they sucked and when you are 4-12 you are losing most of the time and have to throw.. If Manning comes with him than I might think about it. The Tebow stuff was more the kicker and the D than a genius game plan.

Arians is interesting but I am not sold completely on him and he is no spring chicken.

I definitely did not want Kelly. Couple a horrible showing in the bowl game with no NFL experience and I say move along.(and now the tool bag has lost a 5 star recruit while he dallied with the NFL)
samaroo
Love it - Bradley

Like it - Lovie (depending on who his OC is)

Would have to be sold on it - McCoy

I really want Bradley, and it seems like the more I read about him, the more I want him.

I really DON'T want either Gruden, Cowher, Arians or any of the NCAA guys who may still want a free lunch in Philly.
VICKtory
Love it: Nolan, Bradley
Like it: Lovie
Ok: Cowher, McCoy
Hate it: everyone else pretty much
HobbEs
Love it: Jon Gruden
Like it: Mike Nolan
Ok: McCoy, Bradley, Arians
Hate it: Jay Gruden, Lovie Smith
HOUSEoPAIN
QUOTE (nephillymike @ Jan 12 2013, 01:59 PM) *
Ex NFL coaches who may or may not be iterested in returning to coaching = Jon Gruden and Bill Cowher.

Ex NFL coaches who are interested = Lovie Smith

Current NFL coordinators = B. Arians, M. McCoy, Jay Gruden, G. Bradley

Current NCAA coaches = B. Kelly

Here's mine:
Love it = Cowher
Like it = Bradley, Jon Gruden
OK with it = Kelly, Smith, Arians
don't like it = McCoy, Jay Gruden


Love it = Cowher, Bradley, Arians
Like it = Jon Gruden, McCoy, Smith
OK with it = B. Kelly
Don't like it = Jay Gruden
D Rock

Love it = Bradley, O'Brien
Like it = McCoy, Chuckie.
OK with = Lovie
Don't like it = Cower, Jay Gruden, Ariens, Kelly, Chip.
navyeagles
Love it = Bradley
Like it = McCoy, Jon Gruden (even though McCoy already Signed with Denver today)
OK with it = Arians, Kelly (both)
don't like it = Cowler, Jay Gruden, Bellick and Obrien (I think Bill Obrien would be great, but im a penn state fan, need him there)


nephillymike
Since the search has ended, here is the final score of those coaches we voted on. Chip was "gone" by then.

Love It = 4 pts
Like It = 3 pts
OK with it = 2 pts
Hate It = 1 pts

Bradley = 33/9 = 3.67
Smith = 19/8 = 2.37
Cowher - 18/8 = 2.25
John Gruden = 20/9 = 2.22
McCoy = 20/9 = 2.22
Arians = 16/9 = 1.78
B. Kelly = 12/8 = 1.50
Jay Gruden = 10/9 = 1.11

Excluding Chip, it was clear who everyone wanted. I guess we need to check out the old post to see opinions on Chip.
HOUSEoPAIN
QUOTE (nephillymike @ Jan 16 2013, 05:28 PM) *
Jay Gruden = 10/9 = 1.11


Casey Mathews, Mike Maddux, Ken Brett, Jeremy Giambi, Dom DiMaggio.....

I think we don't need to go after another Fredo Corleone
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2017 Invision Power Services, Inc.