Posts in this topic

[bebina]

* Nothing lasts forever, but making draft decisions on the assumption that Reid won't be here a couple of years from now is just foolish. If nothing else, AR's shown the ability to persist. Saying "well, of COURSE he won't be here when 2014 rolls around, so we CAN'T want him to draft a QB for us!" sounds like whistling past the graveyard by the anti-Reid camp.

* We've had our shortcomings under Andy, but bad QB play hasn't been one of them. Compare McNabb/Kolb/Vick to the Rhodes years, when we were treated to Peete/Detmer/Hoying. There's a strong argument to be made that McNabb is the greatest QB in franchise history, and he came in as a gifted option QB out of Syracuse. Reid deserves the lion's share of the credit for turning him into a top WCO QB, and the best QB out of that draft class.

* Tannehill's a good prospect, but not somebody you can't find in the 1st round most years. The stronger argument to me is that any QB we draft this year we'll have the time to develop, whereas if we wait a couple more years the need to have a replacement for Vick will really have become urgent. The guy I'm more interested in for us is 6'7" Brock Osweiler, who can probably be had in the 2nd. Less ready to start than Tannehill, but we can afford the time to develop him.

No thanks don't want him..looks like a bust...name the last qb 6'7 or above who had success in the league

I say take B.J. Coleman, Austin Davis, John Brantley in the 5th or 6th and develop them