Printable Version of Topic

Click here to view this topic in its original format

Eagles Forum _ Philadelphia Eagles or Football Related Discussion _ Wentz

Posted by: Zero Oct 30 2017, 05:20 AM

I'm not sure if it was the ignominy of being usurped by Kelly, the year of reflection that ensued or the admission that he's not really a "football guy", but it's beginning to look like Roseman transformed from a misplaced, Machiavellian geek to an effective GM. And it started with the moves he made to acquire 11.

I thought that Philadelphia’s front office was foolish to take [Wentz] second overall, directly ahead of Joey Bosa, Ezekiel Elliott, and Jalen Ramsey. And the Eagles didn’t just take Wentz second overall: They traded the Browns a slew of draft picks to acquire the rights to the no. 2 pick that they used on Wentz, and most analysts at the time agreed that Philly paid too steep a price. According to the draft value chart created by Football Perspective, the Eagles would have made a roughly fair deal if they had sent the Browns their first-, third-, and fourth-round 2016 draft picks in exchange for the package headlined by the no. 2 selection they used on Wentz. Philly did that—but also included a 2017 first-round pick and a 2018 second-rounder. That made the trade a rip-off, per projections.

I’ve long subscribed to the Belichickian mind-set that a team is better served by having more draft picks than by having a single high draft pick. The logic is twofold. The first part is that for as good as scouts are, drafting is a crapshoot. Players can get injured, have off-the-field problems, or—sit down for this one—simply fail to become as effective as scouts expected. ...

Trivia note:
Lee Woodruff, Jack Knapper, Ed Manske, Fritz Ferko, Bernie Lee, Francis Murray, Lou Ghecas, Richard Erdlitz, Tommy Thompson, John Rauch, Bobby Thomason, Norm Van Brocklin, Rick Arrington, John Walton, Jeff Christensen, Kyle Mackey, Scott Tinsley, Casey Weldon, Matt Bahr, Mark Rypien, Jay Fiedler, Ron Powlus, Tim Hasselbeck, Jeff Blake, Jeremy Bloom, Steve Smith, Trent Edwards, Josh Huff, Carson Wentz.

Powered by Invision Power Board (
© Invision Power Services (